The context for the future direction of EU policy and spending is the aim of EU institutions to reaffirm the importance of the European Union, following the UK’s decision to leave, and to seek common purpose on the future of European integration. The debates conducted under the Budget Focused on Results process and the Commission’s ‘reflections papers’ indicate that EU institutions and some Member States want to allocate substantially more funds to EU priorities such as youth employment, managing migration, security, adaptation to climate change and a quicker transition to clean energy.
There are major implications for Cohesion Policy, including the possibilities of less spending on ESIF, an asymmetric approach to convergence, the prioritisation of social cohesion, measures to ensure faster implementation and stronger capacity, alignment with economic governance, revision of the Berlin formula, a different geographical focus and new budgetary sanctions. Apart from the budgetary dynamics of the MFF debate, Cohesion Policy reform depends on the perceived importance of the territorial dimension in post-2020 EU policy objectives, the role accorded to EU Cohesion Policy in responding to EU development needs and challenges, and the spatial allocation of funding.
EU institutions – Commission DGs, the European Parliament, Committee of the Regions, Council and European Court of Auditors – have all contributed to the debate over the past year through conferences, studies, reports and resolutions. National policymakers have also produced some position papers or statements, either on the MFF, the role of Cohesion policy or specific aspects of its implementation. Key issues raised are the added value of the policy, its geographic and thematic targeting, economic governance, simplification and differentiation.
Cohesion policymakers have stressed the value of the policy in delivering collective action in responding to EU objectives related to globalisation, competitiveness and climate change, as well as the capability of smart specialisation strategies in designing and implementing coordinated policy interventions. They also acknowledge that policy reform has to incorporate more flexibility in response to unforeseen challenges, the need for structural reforms to improve effectiveness and ensure that administrations have sufficient capacity, and simplification especially through common rules.
The context for the reform of the MFF is challenging, with downward pressure on major spending areas such as Cohesion Policy and the Common Agricultural Policy. The debate on reforming Cohesion Policy will need to re-establish the added value of Cohesion Policy in this new context, increased budgetary flexibility to deal with unexpected challenges as well as simplification and differentiation of management, performance and the links with economic governance. The wider challenge is to (re)design a future Cohesion policy as part of a coherent, consistent and mutually reinforcing policy framework at EU and Member State levels which recognises that ‘sectoral policy’ objectives – innovation, a low-carbon economy, social inclusion and the integration of migrants – cannot be addressed effectively without taking account of the territorial dimension. The policy framework also needs a reformed economic governance system which can ensure better coordination of economic policies, and appropriate incentives to ensure that structural reforms take place and the quality of government is improved. Greater performance and accountability have been important new additions to the programming and implementation system for ESIF, but have added new complexity to an already complicated implementation system. Finally, there is a need to continue institutional capacity to ensure effective implementation, not just in areas like expertise but also addressing the politicisation of spending decisions and the lack of trust in institutions